Welcome, Guest. Please Login 3dfx Archive
 
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP (Read 497 times)
dlc
Junior Member
**
Offline


Tracker music rulez!

Posts: 83
Belgrade, Serbia
Gender: male
Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
01.05.05 at 04:01:37
 
Anyone can tell me if there is any diference (in real work and speed) betwen Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP (also for Voodoo 5 if it can be founded for PCI)???

So:
Voodoo 4 4500 PCI vs. AGP
Voodoo 5 5500 PCI vs. AGP
Undecided

C Ya!  Wink
Back to top
« Last Edit: 01.05.05 at 04:05:20 by dlc »  

dlc / digital consumator&&www.dlcnet.cjb.net
WWW  
IP Logged
 
voodoo5500
Full Member
***
Offline


Proud 3dfx gamer

Posts: 197
Canada
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #1 - 01.05.05 at 04:25:29
 
@dlc,

No there would'nt be substantial differences, agp models will be a bit better in performance as they run @ 66 mhz bus speed versus pci's 33 mhz.

One advantage of pci models over agp is that they will still run on modern motherboards using agp 1.5v versus voodoo agp requirments of 3.3v.  Wink
Back to top
 

Voodoo 5500 agp&&3dfx 1.04&&Windows 98 SE&&ECS K7S5A Pro&&Athlon XP 2600+&&512 mb&&SB Live! Platinum
 
IP Logged
 
VDX
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #2 - 01.05.05 at 04:46:29
 
well im not an expert but ill tell you in my o/c rig at 400 fsb the v4 4500 agp kicks the v5 5500 pci a$$, now im not sure in a rig where cpu is really holding the card back but ive tested over an over with v4 and v5 and agp is  no contest, its always been this way for me even though ive read how the agp and pci dont vary much,alot of those test were with 1.4 and lower cpu, if someone has a 3200 running at 400 fsb please check it out.

http://service.futuremark.com/servlet/Index?pageid=/orb/projectdetails&projectTy...

now of course lowest setting here, but a agp card with a high fsb system kills same system with pci card in my test
Back to top
« Last Edit: 01.05.05 at 04:55:01 by N/A »  
 
IP Logged
 
edmundoab
God Member
*****
Offline


Settling down back in
Malaysia

Posts: 651
Shah Alam,  MALAYSIA
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #3 - 19.06.05 at 18:27:53
 
yeap using my PCI voodoo 4 now..
a small card to use compared to the Voodoo 5

while I wait for my long RMA return of X800 XL sigh
Back to top
 

2011 Resolution - Liquidating entire collection, all remaining cards are for sale!
WWW 51284480  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #4 - 24.06.05 at 12:06:24
 
oh dear Edmund, what happened? did it go defect?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
LuxKiller65
God Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 680
Luxembourg
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #5 - 24.06.05 at 13:09:51
 
I'd be a lot happier with a V4 than with your XYZ800...

Tongue

Okay fine I only do oldschool gaming right...
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Gemail
Junior Member
**
Offline



Posts: 84
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #6 - 24.06.05 at 16:22:41
 
Quote:
I'd be a lot happier with a V4 than with your XYZ800...
Tongue
Okay fine I only do oldschool gaming right...

Yeah, me too!
Who wants to donate to me a Voodoo 4 PCI?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
LuxKiller65
God Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 680
Luxembourg
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #7 - 25.06.05 at 19:04:55
 
Not donate, but sell, who knows...

Grin

(ME!)
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #8 - 29.06.05 at 00:12:52
 
the 3dfx Voodoo4 4500 PCI is about 2 t 5% slower than the AGP x4 variant, the 3dfx Voodoo4 4500 AGP is byfar the only Voodoo card that can work flawlessly on AGP x4 mode in a 1.5 volt slot.

Tomorrow I'm gonna try and fit a Voodoo4 4500 PCI next to my X800XT PE , and if that works fine, the 5500 PCI will be next , only it's sheer size beats me hehe.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
BFG3dfx
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #9 - 29.06.05 at 00:16:59
 
Voodoo4 4500 PCI is about 2 t 5% slower than the AGP x4 variant


hmm, i dont get those same results with the v5's, i used a 2800 barton to test it out, now maybe it would be closer with a older cpu
Back to top
« Last Edit: 29.06.05 at 00:21:14 by N/A »  
 
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #10 - 29.06.05 at 17:31:07
 
I've tested this once on my old Dual Pentium3 1Ghz once Smiley, the mainboard was an ABiT VP6, witht the VIA Apollo Pro 133A chipset, wonderfull system that was.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
gamma742
God Member
*****
Offline


3Dfx Gamer

Posts: 1668
San Diego, CA  USA
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #11 - 01.07.05 at 20:19:19
 
Quote:
I've tested this once on my old Dual Pentium3 1Ghz once , the mainboard was an ABiT VP6, witht the VIA Apollo Pro 133A chip



What OS on this platform?
Back to top
 

Quantum3D AAlchemy 3 Channel SwapLock/SyncLock System.  Powered by VSA 100 GPUs Running in SLI Mode. 3dfx at it's Best......
gamma742 https://www.facebook.com/bob.waller  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #12 - 03.07.05 at 13:40:34
 
Win2K Pro + SP2 at it's time.
the system setup was:

Dual Intel Pentium!!!/EB 1Ghz
4x 256MB PC-133 ECC Reg.
GainWard GeForce3 Power Pack!!! Golden Sample
3dfx Voodoo5 5500 AGP 64MB Rev.A 2500, remove GF3 for use of this.
SB Live! 1024 Surround

Win2K pro USA + SP2
AM2.5 for Win2K
Detonator 3.22
DX.8.0
Back to top
« Last Edit: 03.07.05 at 13:44:34 by N/A »  
 
IP Logged
 
gamma742
God Member
*****
Offline


3Dfx Gamer

Posts: 1668
San Diego, CA  USA
Gender: male
Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #13 - 04.07.05 at 06:20:42
 
Nice! I really liked my Abit Motherboard, not a dually though.
Back to top
 

Quantum3D AAlchemy 3 Channel SwapLock/SyncLock System.  Powered by VSA 100 GPUs Running in SLI Mode. 3dfx at it's Best......
gamma742 https://www.facebook.com/bob.waller  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Voodoo 4 PCI and AGP
Reply #14 - 04.07.05 at 11:08:55
 
since that I have SMP I would never want to go back to Uni again, when I had that Dual P3/EB 1Ghz, I used it mostly for Quake3 @ 1600 x 1200 x 32 with my good ole GF3 at max detail FSAA x4S and AF x8, with 2 P3/EB CPU's I hit the 70 frames per sec with 1 CPU I only hit the 37 frames per sec., there fore SMP was alot better, I also found out when I was playing Flanker 2.0 and FS 2000 and 2002 this system pwned them with ease, because of Dual CPU.

After this system I had the Dual AthlonMP 2200+ with a Hercules 9700 Pro, it was meant for FS 2002 most of the time and Quake 3 buut then with the possibillity of FSAA x6 and AF x16 looked lots better, tried FS 2004 on it was way to slow on max detail and density though, ran it on normal details , it was time for something bigger.

So After the Dual AthlonMP 2200+, I sold that and went for a Dual opteronDP 244 setup with ATi's newest X800XT PE VPU based graphics accelerator.
I did a little test with it in FS 2004, but then at max density and max detail

Flight Simulator 2004 works with 1 CPU about 60% faster, I've tested that on my Dual OpteronDP 244, the whole world is in 3D, that cost's lots of CPU power, ram is also a great of importance, for the 3D special effects I use the ASUS ATi X800XT PE Deluxe, only got 1GB of ram, gonna fit another 1x TwinX Corsair XMS Platinum 2x 1GB PC 3200 Low Latency ECC Reg, so I have a total of 3072MB aka 3GB of ram, to fly on reso 1600 x 1200 x 32 at max detail and max density with FSAA x6 T3[ FSAA x18 ] and AF x16 with a playable frame rate of 53 frames per sec, and an Athlon64 3200 + S754 the one I had before the Dual OpteronDP 244 was way too slow, i tried the same settings it only got like 23 frames per sec.

It's also because that the OpteronDP CPU 3 Hyper Transport links has and a dual OpteronDP has then 6 in use, an Athlon64/64 FX has on 1 in use and a X2 has 2, thanx to AMD's Hyper Transport technology, thier CPU's don't need so much Mhz to keep up with others, the more HyperTransport links the lesser Mhz/Ghz they need to keep up.

That's where the OpteronDP comes in to place, in FS 2004 I have 6 Hyper Transport links in use, with my A643200+ the one I sold a short time ago, only had 1, it ran at 2Ghz and had 1MB of L2, yes it was a Clawhammer., my 2 OpteronDP 244's run at just 1.8Ghz per CPU and also have 1MB of L2 but also have each 3 Hyper Transport Links, atotal of 6 in use, in 3D mark 2001SE my Dual Opteron Sys scores 22216 points with the  X800XT PE, an Athlon64FX 57 with a GeForce 7800GTX in SLI scores about the same 22218, only 2 points more, the FX 57 runs at 2.8Ghz but it suffers because it only has 1 hyper transport link, my dual Opterons have 3 each it easily keeps up with the fastest FX cpu with the newest GFX set, unbelievable, but true.

here's my proof, click to enlarge:
...

here's my url of it:
http://service.futuremark.com/compare?2k1=8461253

just a default bench at 1024 x 768 x 32 all settings at default under Win2K Pro + SP4 and Omega Catalyst 2.6.0.5a  Omega 5.1

well sorry for the big post, but might as well post everything hehe I was well on my way, this is the reason I use only SMP based systems, even the Pentium4 with Hyper threading has it's advantages, but real SMP is alot better.
Back to top
« Last Edit: 04.07.05 at 11:22:33 by N/A »  
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print