3dfx Archive
http://www.falconfly.de/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl
General Section >> General Discussion >> Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I think)
http://www.falconfly.de/cgi-bin/yabb2/YaBB.pl?num=1096403167

Message started by TM30 on 28.09.04 at 22:26:07

Title: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I think)
Post by TM30 on 28.09.04 at 22:26:07
Today i got my V3 1000 from USA... it was pulled from a PC...
It works good but i measured around 80°C on the GPU in Windows.... I did not run a game or Benchmark. I shutted down imediately ;) How hot can this card become and why didnt they mounted a heatsink? In games this thing easyly would reach 100°C !?!?


Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by gdonovan on 28.09.04 at 22:41:11
It only runs at 125 mhz.

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by NitroX infinity on 28.09.04 at 23:29:46
Hmm, normally a V3 1000 has a small black heatsink. Either someone removed it or it was never present on the card. Wonder why in that case.

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by gdonovan on 28.09.04 at 23:39:23

wrote on 28.09.04 at 23:29:46:
Hmm, normally a V3 1000 has a small black heatsink. Either someone removed it or it was never present on the card. Wonder why in that case.


here we go again.

Compaq V3-1000 = 125 mhz, no heatsink, 16 megs, 2 TMU

Gateway V3-1000 = 143 mhz, heatsink, 8 megs, 1 TMU

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by TM30 on 29.09.04 at 00:15:06
yeah i'm sure there is normally no heatsink because i saw already a couple of cards...

so 80°C are normal.... damn...

i dont feel good when i run it without a heatsink... but i do not want to attatch one... I'm a collector  8)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by FalconFly on 29.09.04 at 00:16:14
It might exhibit the same "Overheat Bug" (confirmed and acknowledged bug, with a Warning issued by Quantum3D for their products) that is inherent to Voodoo2 and especially Banshee's.

From personal experience, Voodoo3 seems affected by it as well.

I know I had been using a Voodoo3 2000 in an K6-2 based System which ran quite cool.
After I swapped the very same Card into an Athlon System, I almost burned my fingers when touching it out of curiosity, despite just running the 2D Desktop, no workload on the Card.

A Voodoo3-3500 I remember was already quite hot back in time. Last time I had it running a FSB133 Athlon Thunderbird System, it became literally lightning hot (could have easily cooked bacon&eggs on it).
So hot, it even kept killing several 586 Fans that I attached to it, within a few weeks of operation, and I eventually had to pull it from the System for the sake of the Card's plain survival.

Same might happen to this card as well, it may very well require a passive Cooler to safely operate under such conditions...
The last Systems I know were "safe" to operate the Banshee and Voodoo3, were 66MHz FSB Systems (all), and most 100MHz FSB Systems (intel Pentium2 or Socket7 K6-2 class).

On Athlon class Boards, the Overheating seems to be omnipresent, although the Voodoo3 can take a hell lot of thermal beating without the user ever knowing (unless he touches the Chip/Cooler of the Card and painfully finds out)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by gdonovan on 29.09.04 at 00:23:29

wrote on 29.09.04 at 00:16:14:
It might exhibit the same "Overheat Bug" (confirmed and acknowledged bug, with a Warning issued by Quantum3D for their products) that is inherent to Voodoo2 and especially Banshee's.


Banshees run so hot (150F is common) That Hank indicated that 3dfx almost had to add a heat spreader to the back of the Banshee cards BUT the Voodoo 3 is based on a smaller micron die that runs much cooler then Banshee or V2.


Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by FalconFly on 29.09.04 at 00:28:25
Well, last time I tested a passive cooled Banshee (no Fan), the Card got almost burned (!)

It failed within 2 Minutes of 2D Operation, and did not recover until I gave it 5 Minutes of cooling.

I know temperatures were way off scale = completely abnormal and beyond any sane design, because this Banshee was the only piece of Hardware that ever got me a physical, no kidding "branding" (unintentional)  :P

People often believe Banshee's / Voodoo3's were meant to run extremely/lightning hot, but that's just not true.
They can become warm (Banshee, Voodoo3 2000) or even very warm/hot (Voodoo3 3000/3500), but never too hot to touch.

If they were running far beyond 80 Degrees Celsius already without 3D Rendering workloads by default, they would actually never have gotten their sale clearance without explicit warning stickers/signs, since people could have easily burned their hands when handling/operating them.
Besides, 3dfx would have had a massive failure rate on these Cards under such conditions.

The Banshee is clocked just slightly higher than a Voodoo2 (no cooler at all), so it has no reason (except the Bug) to become lightning hot at a mere 100 to 110MHz.

It also becomes obvious, once you think about all the IC's/Resistors in close vicinity of the Chip. Those commonly have a thermal design limit of max. 115C, which no piece of Hardware in any PC was ever designed to even remotely approach. Close to these temps, any component would have to be labeled a plain fire hazard.

PS.
Try the Banshee or Voodoo3 in an old Pentium Class AGP System. If my Memory serves me well, those cards (2D Desktop) will hardly become really warm, you can keep your Hand on it indefinitely.
Swap same Cards into an AthlonXP, and you'll burn either the Cards (Banshee), or your Fingers right off then touching it.
(I burned my skin within 0.5 seconds of touching the Banshee's Cooler during my test)

I estimated the Cooler's Temperature at that time at beyond 130C (>260F) (!) , it was like touching the inside of a hot oven when trying to get the finished Pizza out ;)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by gdonovan on 29.09.04 at 00:55:57

wrote on 29.09.04 at 00:28:25:
They can become warm (Banshee, Voodoo3 2000) or even very warm/hot (Voodoo3 3000/3500), but never too hot to touch.


Banshee run hot due to speed, micron size and number of transistors, on a BX chipset board at full load 150F is common. Remember a Voodoo II is split among 3 chips, a Banshee has everything (minus 1 TMU of course) and a 2d core on a single die with a smaller PCB to act as a heatsink.

I have not tried running a Banshee or Voodoo 3 on a "modern" chipset but if they run hotter then on a BX chipset then the modern chipset is doing something wrong like supplying the wrong voltage to the chip.


Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by DenisF on 29.09.04 at 01:31:24
Weird thing is, that my voodoo3 1000 agp [8meg, black heatsink] gets soooooooo hot on my old p733.
almost as hot as falcon's banshee.
And i even modded the cooler, got better epoxy, and a whole lot of stuff to keep it within sane temperatures [sane in human terms, not computer ones]

But my voodoo3 3000 agp, doesn't get hot *at all*, even after hours and hours of rendering 3dmark2001.
And the only thing i modded there was the thermal pad -> AS5.

Bearly hits 30~35c.. it's even cooler than the cpu..

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by FalconFly on 29.09.04 at 02:39:14
Yep, it seems to happen not always.

I have never found out why some Cards still were running normal, while many others heated up like crazy.

It remains an oddity, even more, since Quantum3D never specifically released details of the Bug's exact nature or cause.

Anyway, no other Card I have ever found to become so hot all of a sudden in modern Systems.

I have ATI Rage128, S3 Virge, Voodoo Rush, G200 and alike Cards, in Systems upto Dual AthlonMP 2800+, but they stay absolutely cool in 2D Mode (especially when in power-saving mode).

Even there (2D, Power-Save) , the Voodoo3 often managed to remain extremely hot in some cases, too hot to touch, while comparably clocked/performing Cards stay cool.
Just an odd bug...

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by paulpsomiadis on 29.09.04 at 19:05:10
Hmm...it would be interesting if we could find out WHY this bug occurs - especially with Athlon systems for some reason? ???

I also have a V3 1000 which I had to fan-mod and add a heat spreader to the back of the chip to keep cool (like @Falcon said - you REALLY could cook fried eggs on the thing!) :o

Yo @Voodude, do you know anything about the specifics of the bug? ???

Oh and @TM30 - the PERFECT heatsinks / fan combo for a V3 1000 is the heatsinks off of an old (in my case 'dead') Matrox G400. ;)

I used the main heatsink from the matrox GPU for the front of the V3 1000 GPU (sawed off the 'feet' from the heatsink), along with a 12v 40mm fan that I bought. ;D

Then I froze the old G400 and removed the small heatsink from the MGA chip - used it as a heat spreader on the 'silver' area at the back of the V3 1000 GPU. :D

Arctic alumina was used throughout the process... 8)

Nuff said! ;)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by TM30 on 29.09.04 at 23:07:35
yeah right falconfly... i heard it too that the voodoos do overheat in some newer configs... but forgot it already  ::)

Is it the same on voodoo 5 ? or only on older voodoos? because i just set up a voodoo PC with a Athlon XP @2500Mhz on a KT333 Board  ;D

and i will test this Voodoo 3 1000 on an old P2 Sys... that must be somwhere behind someplace  ;D 8)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by paulpsomiadis on 29.09.04 at 23:19:21
I can verify that a V5500 AGP 'does' overheat in this way when used in an Athlon... ::)

But the PCI version will NOT! 8)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by TM30 on 29.09.04 at 23:21:30
shit...

to the other members: same experiences on voodoo 5 ?

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by FalconFly on 29.09.04 at 23:32:48
Nope, those should run perfectly fine, never noted a similar Problem with them :)

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by omega_supreme on 29.09.04 at 23:41:27
me neither  ;D

Title: Re: Max temp of a Voodoo 3 1000 (=Velocity200 I th
Post by voodoo5500 on 30.09.04 at 04:53:37
I also have had no XP problems what so ever  ;)

Always run my modded agp model overclocked @ 191 mhz, so an overheating heat issue is out of the question for me at least  ;D

3dfx Archive » Powered by YaBB 2.4!
YaBB © 2000-2009. All Rights Reserved.