Welcome, Guest. Please Login 3dfx Archive
 
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Unidentified Cards (Read 498 times)
Thema
Senior Member
****
Offline


Hardcore Powah

Posts: 485
Slovenia
Gender: male
Unidentified Cards
08.09.05 at 18:50:18
 
Now since I have had unidentified 3Dfx cards and I noticed that other collectors also have some of theirs unidentified I tought about creating a topic (this topic) for us users to post our unidentified card's pics, and share knowledge, this also would go for "I have seen something somewhere" situations, just feel free to post the card's pic
(!to prevent flooding the topic I would advise to everyone to first look at FalconFly's identifiying sub-page http://www.falconfly.de/identify-3dfx.htm before posting some pics)

Also.. try to post thumbnails with links to the hi-res pics so noone gets bandwith-hurt
Back to top
« Last Edit: 08.09.05 at 18:54:34 by Thema »  
 
IP Logged
 
Eye-Q
God Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 522
Germany
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #1 - 08.09.05 at 19:22:18
 
Quote:
(!to prevent flooding the topic I would advise to everyone to first look at FalconFly's identifiying sub-page http://www.falconfly.de/identify-3dfx.htm before posting some pics)

Another good site for identifying 3dfx-cards is 3dfx.cz where some more cards are listed.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Thema
Senior Member
****
Offline


Hardcore Powah

Posts: 485
Slovenia
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #2 - 08.09.05 at 19:29:09
 
True indeed, I was not sure if mention it or not... but, you just did and such a link in a topic like this is welcome.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #3 - 08.09.05 at 20:10:24
 
hmm 3dfx.cz has lots og false info, that's the disadvantage of that site, the best place for ID'n cards would be Gary's place Smiley

http://www.thedodgegarage.com/3dfx/

the most types and all sorts are stored there, it's a real showcase, what you also could do is go to Surrimugge's website Smiley

http://www.3dfx.ch/gallery/3dfx_collectors
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Thema
Senior Member
****
Offline


Hardcore Powah

Posts: 485
Slovenia
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #4 - 09.09.05 at 20:16:27
 
Well about identifying sites, since I intend to make a little 3dfx page, I was thinking to make an identifying sub-page combining NitroX's list with pics, all this made in a reliable way, so there is no wrong info/pics like on 3dfx.cz
By pics I meant good photos taken by us collectors so we don't have lo-res 3rd-party pics and for that I would sure need some help here at falconfly's

If anyone might be interested in such project feel free to give some opinions.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
NitroX infinity
YaBB Moderator
*****
Offline



Posts: 1936
The Netherlands
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #5 - 10.09.05 at 10:16:53
 
My list isn't exactly complete and accurate either.
For instance, I listed the Q3D Voodoo Graphics cards as the Obsidian 50 series and Obsidian 100SB series.

Still need to elaborate on that. Don't put all your money on one horse is all I can say.
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Thema
Senior Member
****
Offline


Hardcore Powah

Posts: 485
Slovenia
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #6 - 10.09.05 at 17:51:15
 
Well we'll have to work together then and doublecheck everithing, and in my opinion the best info we can get is directly from a specific card's owner so every item on the list is properly checked.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
ps47
God Member
*****
Offline


Keeper of the 3Dfx Helppage

Posts: 988
Slovakia,central Europe
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #7 - 14.09.05 at 14:56:36
 
Quote:
hmm 3dfx.cz has lots og false info, that's the disadvantage of that site..

woah,hold your horses.can you tell me where?
Back to top
 
296989413  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #8 - 14.09.05 at 23:40:22
 
Sorry I got no horses Tongue,

Frankly I was mixed up with this site:
http://www.3dfx.cz/3dfx.htm

eum woops. Roll Eyes
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
ps47
God Member
*****
Offline


Keeper of the 3Dfx Helppage

Posts: 988
Slovakia,central Europe
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #9 - 15.09.05 at 00:39:52
 
yeah but can you show me that "lot of false info" there?
Back to top
 
296989413  
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #10 - 16.09.05 at 03:05:13
 
yeah there are plenty things to name about.

Voodoo 4 - 4800 AGP
jádro        166-183 MHz  ----->166Mhz
paměti        166-183 MHz  ----->166Mhz
64 MB SDRAM
trianglerate        > 10 MT/s
fillrate        333-366 MTexel / s
RAMDAC        350 MHz
sběrnice        AGP 4
výstupy        D-Sub, DVI, TV


Voodoo 4 - 4800 již nevyšla. Od verze 4500 se měla lišit především výstupem TV-out a DVI. Karta vychází ze stejného PCB, jako V4-4500; to je ale plně osazeno (64MB, TV-out, DVI).


Voodoo 4 - 4800 PCI ----->Voodoo4 4500 PCI
jádro        166-183 MHz   ----->166Mhz
paměti        166-183 MHz ----->166Mhz
32 MB SDRAM
trianglerate        ~ 10 MT/s
fillrate        333-366 MTexel / s
RAMDAC        350 MHz
sběrnice        AGP 4 / PCI ----->PCI Only
výstupy        D-Sub, DVI, TV


Voodoo 4 - 4800 PCI by pravděpodobně disponovala 32MB, jde v podstatě o V4MAC s osazeným TV-out.

they refer this as a Voodoo4 4800 PCI:
...

but it's actually a Voodoo4 4500 PCI 32MB With DVI/TV-Out.

then we have the great hoax talk about the Voodoo5 6500:

Voodoo 5 - 6500 ----->2x2 Comdex 1999 V56K
jádro        183 MHz ----->183Mhz V3 3500 cores
paměti        183 MHz ----->183Mhz  5.4ns Toshiba
128 (256?) MB SDRAM ----->128MB
32 (64?) MB na čip 1 ----->4x 32MB aka total of 128MB
512bit (4*128)
trianglerate        ? ----->none, card does not function!
fillrate        1466 MTexel / s ----->none, card does not function!
RAMDAC        350 MHz ----->none, card does not function!
sběrnice        AGP 2
délka        250 mm



then under that there is a graph with all the rev's well there a lot's of them that are not filled in propperly with the right ram speeds and timings.

there is als this little graph:

210-0391-001-A0 [0700]  první revize, Intel, 5,4 ns Toshiba

210-0391-001-A1 [1500]  první revize, Intel, 5,4 ns Toshiba
210-0391-001-A2 [2600]       druhá revize, HiNT, 5,4 ns Toshiba --->5,5 ns Toshiba Wink
210-0391-001-A3 [3400]       třetí revize, HiNT, Toshiba, asi 5,4 ns
210-0391-001-A [3700]       poslední revize, HiNT, 6 ns Hynix, záruka funkční karty

210-0391-001-A [3900] poslední revize, HiNT, 6 ns Hynix, záruka funkční karty 12 layers as only difference aside Rev.A 3700 model.

the type of 6K with this picture:
...
is not a Rev.A 3700 but a Rev.A3 3400 with 183Mhz cores and 183Mhz 5.4 ns Toshiba SDRAM Wink

and also the info about the Voodoo5 5200 AGP 64MB DDR isn't correct well let's say sure either:

Voodoo 5 - 5200
jádro        cca 200 MHz
paměti        cca 200MHz
2*64 MB DDR
fillrate        cca 800 MTexel / s
RAMDAC        350 MHz
sběrnice        AGP 4


Voodoo 5 - 5200 měla nahradit Voodoo 5 - 5500. Návrhy této karty jsou hotové, 14 dní po uzavření společnosti měl být vyroben prototyp. PCB 5200 vychází z PCB Voodoo 4 - 4200 AGP, které bylo schválně navrženo tak, aby tento krok snadno umožnilo. Pokud se podíváte na obrázek (např. nahoře na této stránce), tak si všimnete, že PCB je velice úzké a čip s pamětmi je umístěn poměrně blízko u sebe. To bylo cílené. Jednoduchou úpravou je pak možné vytvořit Voodoo 5 - 5200. Nabízím jednoduché schéma:

the idea is wel thought of but still isn't real exsisting info that is stored in the 3dfx archives.
on this picture they have created the Voodoo5 5200 design:
...
well thought but it's morely a hoax and some well created Photoshop work Wink

same as for the result:
...

That wouldn't even bepossible the VSA-101's are too close too each other though it's still well thought ofcourse. but since when does a Voodoo5 have a TV-out hehe 8) Man that would of been Wacko to have around, and the size also so small!

that are some details which arn't correct. though I did correct them Wink

Back to top
« Last Edit: 16.09.05 at 03:37:23 by N/A »  
 
IP Logged
 
gdonovan
YaBB Administrator
*****
Offline


Infernal Collector

Posts: 2361
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #11 - 16.09.05 at 05:27:55
 
Just some food for thought which I have NEVER seen anyone consider.

I think 3dfx only planned for the 6000 to run at 183 mhz, after all I have not ever seen one single 4500 or 5500 equipped with 5.5 ns ram.

Ever.

Why have a 4500 run at 183 when you can purchase a 5500, why have a 5500 run at 183 when you can buy a v5-6000?

I bet that was the plan since a big thing about the choice for ram was price and 5.5 is cheaper then 6 ns.

The only reason I can see a 4500 running at 183 is for marketing or jerking around on a benchmark but in Quake 3 benches the difference isn't enough to get excited about.
Back to top
 

Rampage is alive!
 
IP Logged
 
Obi-Wan_Kenobi
Ex Member


Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #12 - 16.09.05 at 12:20:36
 
I rather see benches in Unreal, Unreal Tournament, Tactical Ops or even Descent3, they all have 3dfx Glide, which is more interesting.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
ps47
God Member
*****
Offline


Keeper of the 3Dfx Helppage

Posts: 988
Slovakia,central Europe
Gender: male
Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #13 - 16.09.05 at 13:43:44
 
aww,c'mon.I'm pretty sure some v4 prototypes report as v4 4800 (I have seen a pic somewhere),and about the chip frequency,this is just how the final card may have been clocked (but it was never released,so no one will ever know for sure).this is not a "false info",just the authors assumption (there is plenty of space for that when you want to talk about the prototypes).

the v5 6500 (the 2x2 not functional prototype): not sure about this,so I'm not going to argue.

5,5 ns Toshiba memory on the second rev (first hint rev) v5 6k cards: can someone confirm this? if its really true I'll pm no-x and he'll fix it.

the picture of that v5 6k: possible.if you have more then thousand pictures sometimes the info its not 100% correct.especially with prototype cards.again,can someone confirm this?

v5 5200 DDR: this is,once again,just the authors concept how the card may have looked like (he created that picture in mspaint Grin),and his assumption of the cards parameters.this is just a theory,but a good one (he actually wrote that the first prototype would be finished 14 days after 3dfx went down,dunno from where he got that info)..


same goes for rampage.half of the info you can find is just theory,simply because there is not enough of 100% verified info available.but for example,if someone who is good with hardware (I'm not Tongue) looks at the specs,he can guess how fast the card would be pretty easily..as I said,if you have just one prototype and only a handful of verified info,the only limitation is your own imagination Grin


so I would say yes,small errors hapen (all the time Wink),but I would certainly not call if "lot of false info" (false info would look like "voodoo3 had 3 TMUs,32mb of memory and was twice as fast as TNT2") or "hoax".theories maybe,or personal theories but certainly not hoax..
Back to top
« Last Edit: 16.09.05 at 13:49:20 by ps47 »  
296989413  
IP Logged
 
gary s donovan
Guest


Re: Unidentified Cards
Reply #14 - 16.09.05 at 15:24:22
 
Quote:
aww,c'mon.I'm pretty sure some v4 prototypes report as v4 4800



4500 = 32 mb
4800 = 64 mb
5000 = 32 mb
5500 = 64 mb

Never has a 4500/5500 prototype board been spotted with 5.5 ns ram and I think I have most of them including the first 4500 PCB revision and the first 5500 PCB revision.

Quote:
the v5 6500 (the 2x2 not functional prototype): not sure about this,so I'm not going to argue.



5.4 ns ram.

I have a 2600 A2 V5-6000 here and it has 5.5 ns ram.

The clockspeed on the V5-6000 was dropped in a vain attempt to make it stable. I say vain since the problem was a design flaw that had nothing to do with clockspeed.

Daytona SLI- Yes 3dfx was considering a Daytona 5500 & 6000 but I'm sure the projects would have been canned. With Rampage up and running starting a new project that duplicate efforts would have not been smart and Daytona was a chip for OEM market.

IF the Daytona 5500 was made it would have been a stacked design.

Quote:
same goes for rampage.half of the info you can find is just theory,simply because there is not enough of 100% verified info available.



Why I always go right to the source.

Gary (my main computer is offline at the moment)
Back to top
« Last Edit: 16.09.05 at 21:54:20 by gdonovan »  
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print